Scout Ahead https://www.scoutahead.org/plans/venturing-boards-of-review/steps/01KZHDDV58N2VRPDN4XNFF6H3T

Requirement · part of 8.0.7.0. The crew president and the chair must agree the final membership

8.0.7.0. If they cannot agree, the crew Advisor decides

Required May not apply

This may not apply to you. You have not answered "Which rank is this board of review for?" yet. Answer it and this step will either settle or drop off.

The Guide supplies the tie-break rather than leaving it open: where the chair and the crew president cannot agree, the candidate's crew Advisor makes the final determination, considering the members the two of them discussed.

Where this step comes from

  1. Guide to Advancement (2025), Section 8.0.7.0 · If the chair and crew president cannot agree, the crew Advisor makes the final determination.

Back to the whole plan