Scout Ahead https://www.scoutahead.org/plans/scouts-bsa-advancement-mechanics/steps/01KZKJ69H1C0WADQ0VJSFH69SK

Task · part of 4.2.1.5. A signed-off requirement has been met and CANNOT be rescinded

4.2.1.5. If the leader doubts the learning: practice or teach, never retest

Recommended

Where a unit leader believes a Scout has not learned the subject matter of a requirement that was signed off, the Guide's answer is to have the Scout practice or teach it. The Scout completes the learning and develops the skill further without being retested.

Notes and warnings

Tip. Worth having ready as a sentence, because the instinct in the moment is to retest. "Let's have you teach that to the new Scouts on Saturday" satisfies the Guide and fixes the actual problem; "show me again" does not, and asks the Scout to prove something already settled.

Where this step comes from

  1. Guide to Advancement (2025), Section 4.2.1.5 · Where a unit leader believes the subject matter was not learned, the Scout should practice or teach the requirement, completing the learning without being retested.

Back to the whole plan