Scout Ahead https://www.scoutahead.org/plans/merit-badge-miscellany/steps/01KZRRF44N59ZSJ6PPZ7RA3KJ7

Requirement

7.0.4.6. The same holds if the counselor turned out not to be registered

Required Often forgotten

Where a Scout, without intent to violate procedure, fulfilled the requirements with someone not registered and approved, the badge still stands. The Guide gives the example: a counselor inadvertently dropped from a charter, or whose membership had expired, but who remained on an approved list.

Notes and warnings

Warning. This is the one that gets units into trouble both ways. A badge earned in good faith from someone who had quietly dropped off a charter still stands, and stripping it is not an available response. What is available is telling the council so the counselor list can be put right.

Where this step comes from

  1. Guide to Advancement (2025), Section 7.0.4.6 · The same holds where the requirements were fulfilled, without intent to violate procedure, with someone not registered and approved.