Requirement · part of 9.0.2.1. What a candidate has the right to expect
9.0.2.1. A rejection explained in writing, and a route to a second opinion
Required Often forgotten
If the Scout or a parent or guardian asks, an explanation of a rejected proposal is provided in writing, copied to the council advancement chair and staff advisor, giving reasons and suggestions for achieving approval. Redress is available where there has been mistreatment or a proposal was wrongly rejected.
Notes and warnings
Tip. Ask for the explanation in writing. The Guide gives the Scout or the parent that right outright, and the copy going to the council advancement chair and staff advisor is what makes the second opinion possible.
Where this step comes from
- Guide to Advancement (2025), Section 9.0.2.1 · A written explanation of a rejection on request, copied to the council advancement chair, and a method of redress including a second opinion.